Blog

Starting seeds indoors can be a rewarding step in gardening. It allows you to get a head start on the growing season, select the best plant varieties, and save money compared to buying seedlings. However, success depends on a few key factors, two of which are the right soil mix and the proper seed trays. 

In this episode, we’ll explore the best soil options for seed starting, the different types of seed trays, and practical tips to maximize germination and seedling health.

The Importance of Good Soil for Seed Starting

Why Soil Matters for Seed Germination

When it comes to starting seeds, soil isn’t just a growing medium—it’s a foundation for strong, healthy seedlings. Seeds need the right balance of moisture, air, and warmth to germinate successfully. Using the wrong soil can lead to poor germination rates, slow growth, and weak seedlings.

Garden soil, – while great for established plants, is not ideal for seed starting because:

• It compacts easily, limiting root development.
• It often contains weed seeds, pests, or pathogens that harm young seedlings.
• It drains poorly, leading to overwatering and fungal issues.

Seed-Starting Mix vs. Potting Soil: What’s the Difference?

A seed-starting mix is specifically designed for germinating seeds. It is light, well-draining, and fine-textured, which allows for delicate root development. In contrast, potting soil is heavier and contains added nutrients that may be too strong for young seedlings.

A good seed-starting mix typically contains:

• Coco coir or peat moss – Holds moisture without compacting.
• Perlite or vermiculite – Improves aeration and drainage.
• Compost (optional) – Provides mild nutrients for early growth.

Peat Pellets

Peat pellets are small, compressed discs of peat moss that expand when soaked in water, creating a self-contained growing environment for seeds. They are a popular choice for seed starting, especially for beginners, but they come with both benefits and drawbacks.

Pros

• Convenient & Mess-Free – No need to mix or handle loose soil.
• Easy Transplanting – Roots grow through the biodegradable mesh, reducing transplant shock.
• Space-Saving – Compact when dry, making them easy to store.
• Good Moisture Retention – Helps keep seeds hydrated during germination.

Cons

• Can Stay Too Wet – Poor drainage can lead to damping-off disease.
• Limited Nutrients – Peat lacks essential nutrients, so seedlings may need fertilization after sprouting.
• Mesh Can Restrict Roots – Some seedlings struggle to push through the mesh, potentially causing root binding.
• Mesh doesn’t break down very quickly
• Environmental Concerns – Peat harvesting is unsustainable; alternatives like coco coir pellets are more eco-friendly.

DIY vs. Store-Bought Seed-Starting Mix

If you enjoy a hands-on approach, making your own seed-starting mix can be both cost-effective and customizable. A simple recipe includes:

• 4 parts coco coir or peat moss
• 2 parts perlite or vermiculite
• 1 part finely sifted compost (optional, but beneficial)

This mix ensures proper moisture retention and prevents soil from becoming too dense. Store-bought mixes are convenient and often sterilized to prevent fungal growth, making them a good choice for beginners.

Best Soil Mixes for Different Crops

Not all seeds have the same needs. Here’s a quick guide to optimizing your soil mix based on seed size:

• Fine seeds (lettuce, basil, tomatoes, peppers) – Use a very light mix with extra fine-textured ingredients.
• Larger seeds (squash, beans, cucumbers) – A slightly heavier mix with more organic matter supports strong early root growth.

Choosing the Right Seed Trays

Types of Seed Trays

Choosing the right tray impacts root development, transplant success, and overall plant health. The most common options include:

1. Standard 1020 Trays

• Best for: Holding seed cells, soil blocks, or microgreens.
• Pros: Versatile, reusable, and great for bottom watering.
• Cons: Can be flimsy unless you invest in sturdy versions.

2. Air pruning Seed Trays

• Prevents root circling, which can lead to root-bound plants.
• Encourages more lateral root growth, leading to stronger, more resilient transplants.
• Improves nutrient and water absorption, reducing transplant shock.
• Allows for better oxygenation in the root zone, promoting faster growth.

Bootstrap Farmer 72 Cell Air Prune Tray, 10 Pack – https://amzn.to/4k5kCnK 

3. Plug Trays

• Best for: Growing many seedlings in a small space.
• Pros: Allows for easy transplanting; reduces root disturbance.
• Cons: Small cells dry out quickly, requiring frequent watering.

4. Soil Blocks (Block Trays)

• Best for: encouraging strong roots.
• Pros: Air pruning prevents root circling; reduces transplant shock.
• Cons: Requires a soil blocker tool and careful watering.

1020 Mesh Tray Soil Blocking Tray – https://amzn.to/4gVSMYw 

Ladbrooke Soil block makers kit: https://amzn.to/4gW5SVG

Craig Schaaf videos on soil block making: https://rumble.com/user/Schaafcraig?q=soil%20block

5. Biodegradable Trays (Peat Pots, Cow Pots, etc.)

• Best for: Direct planting into the garden.
• Pros: No transplant shock since seedlings go straight into the ground.
• Cons: Can mold or break down too quickly if overwatered.

CowPots – https://cowpots.com/ 

Biodegradable Peat Pots – https://amzn.to/4jYgeqy 

Drainage & Airflow Considerations

Seedlings are prone to damping-off disease, a fungal issue caused by excess moisture and poor airflow. To prevent this:

• Use trays with good drainage holes.
• Avoid overwatering—bottom watering is ideal for even moisture.
• Place trays in an area with good air circulation or use a small fan.

Sustainability & Reusability

For long-term use, invest in sturdy, reusable plastic trays rather than flimsy disposable ones. When reusing trays:

• Sterilize with a diluted bleach or hydrogen peroxide solution to kill pathogens.
• Inspect for cracks or warping before each season.

Practical Tips for Seed Starting Success

Watering Methods

• Misting is ideal for delicate seeds but requires frequent monitoring.
• Bottom watering encourages strong root growth and prevents surface mold.

Lighting Needs

• Natural Light: A south-facing window may work, but seedlings often grow leggy without supplemental light.
• Grow Lights: LED or fluorescent lights positioned appropriately above seedlings ensure strong, compact growth.

Temperature & Humidity

• Use a heat mat for warmth-loving crops like tomatoes and peppers (~70-80°F).
• Cover trays with a humidity dome to retain moisture during germination, but remove it once seedlings sprout.

Troubleshooting Common Issues

Poor Germination Rates?

• Check seed age—old seeds lose viability.
• Keep the soil consistently moist but not soggy.
• Ensure the right temperature for each plant type.

Mold & Fungus Growth?

• Improve airflow with a fan.
• Water less frequently.
• Use perlite or vermiculite on top of soil.

Leggy Seedlings?

• Move grow lights closer to prevent stretching.
• Lower temperature slightly to slow rapid vertical growth.

Transplant Shock?

• Harden off seedlings by gradually introducing them to outdoor conditions for a week before planting.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right soil mix and seed trays is essential for a successful seed-starting setup. Whether you opt for a store-bought or DIY soil mix, plastic or biodegradable trays, or experiment with soil blocks, understanding your plants’ needs will set you up for gardening success.

Have you tried different soil mixes or trays? Share your experiences and tips in the comments below!